Fake Food Alert: How to Spot Counterfeit or Mislabeled Friskies & Fancy Feast and Buy Safely - Cat Blog | PetCurious
Dog Breeders Dogs for Sale
  1. PetCurious
  2. Pet Blog
  3. Cat Blog
  4. Fake Food Alert: How to Spot Counterfeit or Mislabeled Friskies & Fancy Feast and Buy Safely

Fake Food Alert: How to Spot Counterfeit or Mislabeled Friskies & Fancy Feast and Buy Safely

Fake Food Alert: How to Spot Counterfeit or Mislabeled Friskies & Fancy Feast and Buy Safely - Cat Blog | PetCurious
Search our cat listings!
Keeping your cat safe starts with the food you buy. Big brands like Friskies and Fancy Feast can show up on online marketplaces with gray-market imports, short-dated or repackaged cans, or damaged stock. This guide explains simple checks you can do before and after buying so you and your cat stay safe.

Why this matters

When a can is counterfeit, mislabeled, or stored badly it can put your cat at risk. Even when a product is not a fancy fake, short-dated or damaged food can spoil or grow bacteria that make pets sick. Learning a few label and listing tricks helps you avoid problems and makes it easier to get a refund if something goes wrong.

Cats near Chicago

Where to buy safely

Stick to sellers that source directly from manufacturers or fulfil their own stock whenever possible. Trusted options include big pet retailers and the brand's official storefronts like Purina, and retailers that ship their own inventory rather than third-party marketplace sellers.
  • Chewy — generally sources from brands and fulfills its own orders.
  • Petco and PetSmart — large retailers with direct sourcing and store/warehouse fulfillment.
  • Major grocery and big-box stores (Target, Kroger, Publix, Walmart when sold and shipped by Walmart).
  • Official Purina brand store and listings sold by Nestlé Purina or Amazon.com when available.

How to spot suspicious listings

Before you click Buy, read the listing like a detective. Check can size, total count, photos, seller history, and price for mismatches or oddities.
  • Net weight and can size: Fancy Feast classic pâtés are commonly 3 oz (85 g); Friskies pâtés are often 5.5 oz (156 g). A title/photo mismatch is a red flag.
  • Missing U.S. label elements: U.S. cans should show an AAFCO nutrition statement, guaranteed analysis, and a Nestlé Purina PetCare distributor line. Foreign-only labels often indicate gray-market imports.
  • Variety pack signs: Official multipacks come in printed boxes or factory shrink-wrap with barcodes; loose or single cans from factory packs marked 'Not labeled for individual sale' are suspect.
  • Price too low or vague titles: Extremely cheap listings, stock-photo-only images, or vague 'assorted flavors' text often hide problems like short-dated or repackaged stock.

Marketplace signals and seller checks

Look at who is selling and how they ship the item. Favor listings that say 'Ships from and sold by' the retailer name or the brand.
  • On Amazon, prefer 'Sold by Amazon.com' or the Nestlé Purina PetCare listings and consider A-to-z Guarantee coverage for third-party purchases.
  • On Walmart, choose items sold and shipped by Walmart rather than Marketplace sellers unless the seller has strong reviews.
  • Read recent low-star reviews for mentions of expired, dented, or foreign-labeled cans — these point to recurring issues.

What to check when your order arrives

Inspect the box and the cans before feeding any of the food to your cat. Take photos of everything as soon as you open the package.
Fake Food Alert: How to Spot Counterfeit or Mislabeled Friskies & Fancy Feast and Buy Safely - Cat Blog | PetCurious
  • Outer packaging: Factory cartons or shrink-wrap with barcodes are normal; excessive re-taping or generic packing suggests repackaging.
  • Can condition: Reject swollen, leaking, or seam-dented cans — these can be unsafe. Mild cosmetic dents away from seams may still be returned if you prefer.
  • Best If Used By date and lot code: These are usually ink-jetted on the bottom of cans and on the outer carton. Photograph date, lot code, and UPC before opening.
  • Label language and details: U.S. cans should have English label content, net weight in oz and g, the AAFCO statement, and a U.S. distributor line (Nestlé Purina PetCare, St. Louis, MO).

If you suspect a problem

If something seems wrong, stop feeding immediately and keep samples and photos. Document everything and contact both the retailer and Purina for help.
  • Stop feeding and keep at least two unopened cans from the same lot if possible.
  • Document with photos of the listing, outer box, can bottoms (date/lot), UPC, and any damage or off-odor/texture.
  • Contact the retailer for a refund or replacement and provide your evidence; use platform protections like Amazon's A-to-z Guarantee if needed.
  • Contact Purina Consumer Care so they can verify lot norms and request samples if necessary; you can also check Purina recall notices.
  • Report safety concerns to the FDA's Safety Reporting Portal if you suspect misbranded, adulterated, or unsafe pet food.

Extra tips to reduce risk

Compare suspicious cans to a known-good empty can from your usual purchase and check fonts, UPCs, and code format. Calculate price per can and beware deals that are too good to be true.
  • Avoid buying from auctions, social media marketplace posts, or informal sellers without provenance.
  • For prescription Purina veterinary diets, buy only through your vet, Chewy's pharmacy, or authorized channels that require vet authorization.
  • Use a credit card for added protections and easy chargebacks if a seller won’t cooperate.

Where to learn more

For official label rules and what must appear on U.S. pet food, check the FDA and AAFCO guidance. If you need to contact Purina, use their consumer support for product questions or to report suspect lots.
You can read FDA pet food labeling guidance here: FDA: Pet Food Labeling and AAFCO basics here: AAFCO: Understanding Pet Food. For Purina help use: Purina Consumer Support.
Keeping your cat safe is mostly about buying from trusted sellers, checking labels and dates, and documenting problems. A few quick checks will protect your pet and make it easier to get a refund or report an issue when needed.
Search our cat listings!
Back to pet blog
Subscribe now!
$50/month
$10/month!
Unlimited pet listings!
Business profile!
Anywhere in the World!
Guaranteed visibility!
Monthly. Cancel anytime!